Back to the magazine2019 year №3

Domestic Violence іn Ukrainian Traditional Culture

Read the postRead the postDownload the post
The authors of the publication:
Ihnatenko Iryna
p.:
56-65
UDC:
392(=161.2)“185/192”
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15407/nte2019.02.056
Bibliographic description:
Ihnatenko, I. (2019) Domestic Violence іn Ukrainian Traditional Culture. Folk Art and Ethnology, 2 (378), 56–65.

Author

Ihnatenko Iryna

a Ph.D. in History, an associate professor at Ethnology and Regional Studies Department of the Taras Shevchenko Kyiv National University

 

DomesticViolence іnUkrainianTraditionalCulture

 

Abstract

An attempt to consider and analyze the problem of domestic violence in traditional peasant culture of the mid­XIXth – early XXth centuries is proposed in the article on the base of the ethnographic sources analysis. This issue has been concealed for a long time. What domestic violence is and why it occures is discussed. Drawing on ethnological sources, the authoress tries to understand the patriarchy significance in the development of domestic violence. The researcher is focused on the uncovering of domestic violence social support, identification of situations where abuse may occur, including family partner violence, child and elderly members.

The scientist proves that husbands have the right from society to punish wives physically in the case of disobedience, betrayal, laziness or wastefulness. The well-grounded violence against women is tolerated by a normative social culture. The gender contradictions are caused primarily by the dominion of a man over a woman. It is important to note, that the status of marriage pride can give women some tolerance for violence from the husband’s side. Fearing to lose her husband and thus the status of being married, women silently suffer domestic violence. In case of very hard domestic violence (alcoholism is a widespread cause of it), rural society tries to limit it. Punishment for an offender is fine or short-term imprisonment but can’t be a strong reason for divorce.

However, physical violence is ubiquitous phenomenon in relationships not only between a husband and a wife but also regarding children and old people. A mother or a father can punish children. Hitting them is believed to be very effective for a good child’s upbringing.

So, while analyzing relationships in families of the mid­XIXth – early XXth centuries, we can see that physical violence is considered as a justified tool. It is used to put an order in the division of gender roles.

 

Keywords

domestic violence, patriarchy, childhood.

 

References

  1. Voronchuk, I. (2010) Dominant Power of Man over Woman in Ukrainian Family of the 16th-17th Centuries (After the Volyn Materials). Mężczyzna w rodzinie i społeczeństwie - ewolucja ról w kulturze polskiej europejskiej [Man in Family and Society: Evolution of Roles in Polish European Culture]. Poznań, Vol. I: Od średniowiecza do początku XXwieku, pp. 77-87.
  2. Hrymych, M. (1991) Folk Culture of Ukrainians as a Mirror of Ukrainian Nationality. Ethnic Identity and National Culture. Kyiv, pp. 34-36.
  3. Hrushevskyi, M., Kuzelia, Z. (2017) A Child in Customs and Folk Beliefs of Ukrainian People(reprint of the 1907 edition). Kyiv: Intelektualna knyha, Pt. 2, 196 pp.
  4. Zahirnia, M. (1912) About the marriage in Ukraine in earlier times. Kyiv: M. Hrinchenko, (Books Commemorating Nastia Hrinchenko; No. 6).
  5. (2018) The Law «On Prevention and Combating against Domestic Abuse». Bulletin of the Supreme Council, No. 5, p. 35.
  6. Ihnatenko, I. (2017) Matrimonial Relations in Ukrainian Conventional Culture. Kharkiv: Family Leisure Club, 240 pp.
  7. Ihnatenko, I. Fathers, Mothers and Their Children in Ukrainian Conventional Society. URL: https://genderindetail.org.ua/season-topic/mater-batkiv/batki-materi-ta-ihni-diti-u-traditsiynomu-ukrainskomu-suspilstvi-134505.html/.
  8. Kis, O. Volyn 1999: Ethnographic Materials from Volyn (Lviv and Volyn Regions). Archives of the Institute of Ethnology, NAS of Ukraine, Fund 1, Inventory 2, Unit od issue 456, 33 sheets.
  9. Kis, O. (2008) Women in Ukrainian Conventional Culture (Second Half of the XIXth - Early XXth Century). Lviv: NASU Institute of Ethnology, 272 pp.
  10. Kravchenko, V. (2009) Collected Works and Materials of Archival Heritage (compiled by O. Ruban) (National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, M. Rylskyi Institute of Art Studies, Folkloristics and Ethnology). Kyiv: IASFE, Vol. 2, 640 pp.
  11. Kurochkin, O. (2004) An Ethnopedagogical Role of the Birch. Ukrainians in the European Family: Customs, Ceremonies, Holidays. Kyiv: Ukrainian's Library, 224 pp.
  12. Litvinova, P. (1885) How the Elderly Were Placed on a Bast Sledge. The Kyivan Past, No. 5, pp. 354-356.
  13. Mayerchyk, M., Plakhotnik, O. (2017) Gender-Related Violence: Between Tradition and Crime. Gender for Media: A Textbook on Gender Theory for Journalism and Other Socio-Humanities(3rded.). Kyiv: Krytyka, pp. 151-164.
  14. Mazurkevych, O., Diachuk, V. (2016) Customary Rules of Decorum in Conventional Culture of Ukrainians. Kyiv: Lira-K, 218 pp.
  15. Masliychuk, V. (2008) On «Fatherhood» and «Maternity» in Left-Bank Ukraine in the Second Half of the XVIIIth Century. Folk Art and Ethnography. Kyiv: IASFE, No. 5(314), pp. 21-26.
  16. Miloradovich, V. (1904). Mode of Life of Lubny District Peasants. The Kyivan Past, No. 5, 6.
  17. (1904) First General Russian Imperial Population Census of 1897. St.Petersburg, Vol. XXX. Podolian Governorate.
  18. Petrenko, I. (2010) Monasticism as a Reason for Divorce of Spouses amongst the XVIIIth-Century Rural Population. The Ukrainian Peasant. Cherkasy: B. Khmelnytskyi Cherkasy National University, Iss. 12, pp. 105-107.
  19. Portnova, T. (2016) Caring and Teaching: What Ukrainian Intellectuals Thought of Peasantry in the Second Half of the 19thCentury. Dnipropetrovsk: Lira, 240 pp.
  20. Opposing Family Violence. The Non-Governmental Organization «La Strada - Ukraine». URL: http://www.la-strada.org.ua/ucp_mod_stat_show-direction_0.html.
  21. Svientsitskyi, I. (1912) Keening (collected by Dr. Iliarion Svientsitskyi). The Ethnographic Collection. Lviv, Vol. XXXІ-XXXІІ.
  22. Starchenko, N. (2016) «Sources Testify»: Some Observations on Studying the Standing of Gentry in the Early Modern Volyn Society. Ukrainian Archeographical Yearbook, Iss. 19-20, pp. 239-268.
  23. Chubinskiy, P. (1869) An Essay on Folk Legal Customs and Legal Conceptions in Lesser Russia. St. Petersburg, 41 pp.
  24. UNICEF. «Hidden in Front of Everyone». URL: http://www.unicef.org/ukraine/ukr/media_25224.html.
  25. Cosimo, S. D. (2012) Domestic Violence / Legal Sanctions and Recidivism Rates among Male Perpetrators. El Paso: LFB Scholarly Pub. LLC, 154 pp.
  26. Raghavan, Ch., Cohen, J. Sh. (eds., comms) (2013) Domestic Violence: Methodologies in Dialogue. Boston: Northeastern University Press, 281 pp.
  27. Harding, S. (1987) Introduction is there a Feminist Method. Feminism and Methodology: Social Science Issues (edited with an introduction by Sandra Harding). Bloomington: Indiana University Press, pp. 3-16.
  28. Hague, G., Mallos, E. (1998) Domestic Violence: Action for Change. Cheltenham: New Clarion Press, 212 pp.
  29. Elliot, F. R. (1996) Gender, Family and Society. Basingstoke: Macmillan; New York: St. Martin's Press, 268 pp.
  30. Shoemaker, B. R. (1998) Gender in English society, 1650-1850: the Emergence of Separate Spheres? London: Longman, 334 pp.